Friday, March 16, 2012

Part 20

A Glimpse Inside the Speedchimp Racing Aerodynamics Laboratory

Part 1 – The Idea & The Concept

24 Hours or LeMons entries can roughly be lumped into four types of cars/teams:
Type 1 – Teams that show up with and race a complete pile of crap that should have been left in the wrecking yard (probably the most prevalent type of entry).

Type 2 – Teams that show up with a really, really good theme including costumes and either an over-the-top art car, or a really good parody of a real race car (a replica of the Oscar Meyer wienermobile or a car with a 20’ blimp attached to the roof).
Type 3 – Teams that show up with a heavily modified monstrosity of car (a Miata with a working moonshine still or a car powered by a 90 year old airplane motor).

Type 4 – Teams that show up with a car that is completely unsuitable for racing (a stretch Limousine for example).

Getting accepted to a race is very dependant on the 24 Hours of LeMons judges being intrigued by your entry and we at Speedchimp Racing had a minor problem.  Even though our car really is a 30+ year old piece of crap, it didn’t really look that bad.  When we started working on it, we began finding some serious problems, but many people who saw the car were surprised that we weren’t going to just fix it up and sell it for a profit.  Something else we learned after purchasing the car is that the LeMons community considers Mazda RX-7s to be a little bit on the “cheaty” side (An opinion that is completely unfounded in my opinion).  For instance, the 1st Generation RX7 utilizes a live rear axle (which can also be found on pickup trucks, Ford Mustangs, mini-vans, and other vehicles known for superior handling) incorporating a Watts Linkage; the cutting edge of 18th century steam engine technology.

We weren’t a Type 1 team because our car was too nice.  We weren’t a Type 3 team because frankly, we don’t have the tools or skills to make those kinds of modifications.  And we weren’t a Type 4 team because regardless of antiquated mechanical design, the RX-7 is still considered a sports car with an actual history of winning races. 

That left us as a Type 2 team and presented a new problem.  With the exception of Melissa, none of us are really what you would consider to be “dress up” people.  Costumes?  Ugh… That story can be covered in another chapter. I’m going to concentrate on the transformation of our worn out RX7 into a fast looking race car.

During the whole creative process for developing our car and theme, we really wanted to stay away from ideas that had already been to death.   Pretty early on we decided that we should pretend our car was something that it very obviously was not, but we didn’t know exactly what.  We had some ideas, but nothing that we were really in love with.  Instead of worrying about the theme, we decided to focus on the huge amount of work the car needed.

Fast forward to the summer of 2011 with my wife and I cleaning and organizing our garage.  While digging through the junk we had accumulated over the years, I came across a stack of drawings from the various drafting classes I had taken in Junior High and High School.  Buried in the stack was a technical drawing I had done of an early ‘80s BMW M1 Procar.  “Hmm,” I thought, “That bears a strong resemblance to our Mazda”.  Later that day I searched the interwebz for pictures of BMW M1s.  While actual photographs of a BMW M1 looked a little bit like an RX-7, it was clear that the A- I had received for my drawing was based more on technique than actual resemblance to the source material.  Still, we hadn’t come up with anything better in the mean time, so I decided to run an idea by the team.
 Mazda RX-7
BMW M1 Procar
The resemblance is uncanny!

The idea: Decorate the car to look like a BMW M1 Procar with the iconic tri-colored diagonal stripe. How hard could it be to fabricate some kind of air dam and a rear wing? Also, our car would be a parody of the M1, so a perfect copy wasn’t really the point.  Instead of calling it a BMW (Bavern Motor-Werken), our car would be an RBW (Reis Brenner-Wagen or Reis Brenner-Wankel). We could wear lederhosen, talk with funny accents, and walk around saying, “I know nuttink”. It would be funny!

The idea was met with some skepticism (“Dude, really? I am skeptical that you are going to get me to wear lederhosen.”), doubt (“I doubt I will wear lederhosen.”), and lack of vision (“Lederhosen? I do not see myself wearing short leather pants”). On the other hand, so far it was pretty much the only idea, and therefore, the best idea. 

There were some pros though; our car was already white, so painting would be relatively easy. And…

 Actually, aside from looking pretty cool, that was the only pro.

Time passed and the RBW theme gradually settled into everyone’s minds as the shortest, easiest route to LeMony glory.

There would be five main components to transforming our car into the mighty RBW7.

1)       The Concept (RBW)

2)       The Wing,

3)       The Air Dam,

4)       The Grill, and,

5)       The Paint.

It would have been nice if these projects were completed in some sort of orderly manner, but this is Real Life.  They weren’t.  There were ups, there were downs, there were unexpected plot twists, and most of all, there were setbacks.

Rather than try to retell all that occurred in historical order, it is probably best to address each project on its own…

The Concept (RBW)

The RBW logos were actually the first thing completed (thanks to Mike).  They turned out rather well we think…

Reis-Brenner Wagen (Rice Burner Wagon)

Part of the LeMons application process requires the team to explain its theme and why your team should be accepted to race (there are routinely more applicants than available grid positions and the judges are looking for “quality” entrants).  We fabricated a story about a fictional German automaker named RBW, threw in some enticing (and possibly misleading) hints about bribes for the judges and posted a picture of the wrong car.  And we were accepted!

Part 2 - The Wing

The Wing was the second project to get started (and the last to be finished).  The first concept for The Wing was nothing more than a piece of plywood bolted to the back of the car and painted white.  Then I thought, “Hey.  I’ve got months to build this thing so why don’t I make an actual wing-shaped wing?” The Wing Mk I was fabricated by cutting plastic and layering the pieces into an airfoil shape with a piece of steel tubing running the span to provide strength.  At this point I had a pretty LeMony wing that would have suited our purposes and I could have easily left well enough alone.

I could have been finished.  I could have begun working on something else.  But I didn’t because something happened…

Completely unrelated to work on the car, I was made aware of a NASA website that allowed for modeling of wings under different conditions.  It was easy enough to plug in the data for our wing and see how much downforce it would make (hardly any at all).  Playing with the software showed that adding camber to the wing shape (see pictures) would increase the efficiency of The Wing and create 30 times as much downforce.  With camber, our wing would actually work.

 Our wing needed camber!
Wing with no camber in the chord
Wing with camber in the chord

I just didn’t know how to go about making it happen.

I knew that the ABS our wing was built from had a pretty low melting point, so I thought maybe I could just heat the plastic and bend it to the shape I wanted.  I mentioned to Mike that I needed some kind of a tube so that I could heat the ABS to the point it became pliable, then use the tube as a form.  Mike suggested that a cardboard tube used for making concrete forms might work.  After performing a little research and doing some math, I determined that a 12” diameter tube (available at Home Depot) would give The Wing 12.5 degrees of camber.  Perfect.

Then I tried to form the ABS. 

And the ABS did not want to form around the tube.  I had made a pretty big error.  Between the steel and plastic used to build it, The Wing weighed about 15 pounds.  The thing simply had too much thermal mass to heat to a point of pliability without completely melting and blistering the outer layers. Also, although the cardboard tube was the perfect shape and length, it didn’t really have much strength, so trying to bend the plastic around it was causing the tube to deform.  This clearly wasn’t working.  I had already managed to deform a corner of The Wing rendering it useless as a zero camber airfoil.  I was back at square one.

The plans for The Wing Mk II had two substantial changes; 1) rather than layer alternating pieces of 24” and 12” pieces of ABS, the wing would be built completely from 48” long pieces of ABS, and, 2) The Wing would be clad in aluminum sheet.  This should be strong enough to prevent The Wing from exploding into a hundred pieces of shredded plastic should there actually be any aerodynamic forces acting upon it.  There was no way that this plan could fail.

After working on The Wing the night of February 29th, I decided that my plan was a failure.  I simply didn’t have the proper equipment to accomplish what I was trying to do and the results of my efforts were terrible (and likely dangerous).  I had already been thinking about The Wing Mk III as a future project for the car and I really had no choice but to abandon my efforts with ABS and go straight to a full aluminum design.

The construction of The Wing Mk III began with designing the ribs and overall size of the airfoil.  The specifics are:
Span: 44”
Chord: 9”
Chord Thickness: ≈10% (about an inch thick)
Camber: ≈11%

I cut a prototype rib out of a piece of aluminum and decided it was good.  Attempting to exactly duplicate the shape was difficult (it is almost impossible to cut through 4 stacked pieces of 1/8” aluminum sheet with any kind of accuracy).  I ended up employing a “Snowflake” manufacturing technique.  No two parts were exactly alike.

Attempting to cut all the ribs at one time (unsuccessfully)

While this was going on in my garage, I was also planning the wing uprights.  The biggest challenge here was fastening the uprights to the trunk lid.  I wanted the uprights to be as far outboard as possible, but the space inside the car to secure the fasteners was limited.  The uprights eventually ended up mounted 38” apart.  But The Wing had a span of 44”.  In a metal working shop, a tool called a “Brake” would be used to make precision bends in the aluminum.  The brake we have is nowhere near capable of bending 1/8” aluminum so an alternate method was required.  Several methods failed before a solution was discovered. The method that worked went as follows:

 1) Place a 12” long chunk of wooden 4”X6” on the garage floor.
2) Place aluminum upright on wood block. 
3) Place second piece of 4”X6” on top of aluminum.

4) Carefully align the desired line of bend with edges of wooden blocks.
5) Kneel on top wooden block.
6) Bash aluminum with 15Lb anvil until desired shape is achieved. 

This process took hours (instead of the minutes it would have taken with the correct tools) and required some fine tuning (bashing) with a brass mallet, but the desired bends were achieved and the scars were quickly painted over.

Wing Upright in place
Meanwhile, the lack of proper tools was causing the building of The Wing to take much longer also.  I needed 72 brackets cut from a piece of L shaped aluminum.  This would have been easy work with a bandsaw, but the job was very slow going using only a hacksaw.
Pile of (72) Brackets

Once these were cut, each was matched with a specific location on a rib and marked, and then drilled using the high precision tools available in my garage.
Speedchimp Racing precision drilling station
After the brackets had all been drilled, they were matched up with each rib and riveted into place.
Rib #5 with custom brackets and completed rib assemblies

The ribs were then JB Welded to a ½” square steel tube.  The steel tube would serve two purposes; strengthen The Wing and allow a threaded steel rod to pass through the middle of the wing to tie the two uprights together.  An additional aluminum bar was JB Welded into place on the lower side trailing edge of the wing to keep the ribs parallel and to provide an anchor point for the skin of the wing when I began riveting it in place.

Letting the JB Weld cure

After allowing the JB Weld to cure, I began putting the skin into place.  I won’t go into the details, but my first attempt at skinning The Wing was a catastrophe.  The second attempt at skinning The Wing went much better and was almost completely free of drama or significant problems.

The skin going on The Wing

Skin in place

With the skin in place, the last step of construction was to build end plates.  I originally was going to build these out of aluminum, but I didn’t like the thickness or strength of any of the aluminum that I had in the garage.  I decided to use a piece of steel that I had lying around.  Designing the end plates consisted of; 1) tracing the outline of airfoil shape on a piece of graph paper, 2) determining the imaginary line running through the airfoil that equaled a zero degree angle of attack, 3) finding the imaginary line that equaled a 13 degree angle of attack (this was determined to be the angle at which The Wing would generate the most downforce), and 4) drawing the outline of an endplate that looked decent.  Once the design work was done, the shapes were cut out of the steel plate and riveted to the ends of the wing.

End plates in place and bare metal coated with primer

Part 3 - The Air Dam
The Air Dam is the bit of fabrication that had me the most concerned.  By its very nature, The Air Dam was going to be subject to aerodynamic forces and occasionally dragging on the ground and thus would need to have good inherent strength.  Design and fabrication was also going to be difficult because of the shape of the front of the car.  In short, I really was not looking forward to this part of the build because I had very little confidence that this would turn out decent at all and I really had no idea how to accomplish what I wanted.

Planning consisted primarily of looking at pictures of BMW M1s and thinking about how to shape and mount the thing.  I briefly considered making The Air Dam from aluminum, but decided that ABS would be cheaper in the long run (because I expected to make many mistakes and be forced to start from scratch and ABS costs a lot less).  We had been working on the car for months and I finally decided that the plans in my head weren’t going to execute themselves, so I broke out a tape measure and started estimating the amount of material I would need.

During planning, I couldn’t find a piece of ABS big enough to make the entire thing out of one piece.  A minimum of two were going to be required. The ABS I selected came in 36”X36”X1/8” sheets.  I decided to form one half and see how it went.  I drew some rough lines on the piece of ABS and went after it with a scoring tool and a heat gun.

36” X 36” X 1/8” Sheet of ABS

I had an idea of how the thing should look and fit together with the car, but I struggled to get a design on paper.  I was pretty sure that this was going to be a complete failure…

The first cuts and bends

What happened next was pretty surprising.  The pieces were fitting on the car the way I had envisioned.  Sure, they weren’t perfect and no one would call the results “pretty”, but it was actually working!

Test fitting the first half of The Air Dam

After getting the first half finished, the next trick was duplicating the effort to make a matching second piece.  “Easy”, right?  I was afraid of it being “too easy” and making a horrible mistake, so I really took my time to make sure that the cuts were all going in the right place (a mirrored shape of the first piece).  It worked pretty well. The next step was to fasten the two pieces together.  This was accomplished by sandwiching the plastic between sheets of aluminum then riveting the whole assembly together.  The drilling and riveting was actually the most time consuming portion of the entire project.  Approximately 80 rivets were used for fastening and strengthening The Air Dam.

When mounted on the car, it actually looked pretty good.  Not completely on center (I made quite a few eyeball measurements and estimations during fabrication) and it definitely has a homemade look, but a surprisingly cool result for a project that I had been dreading and with amazingly few mistakes made and material wasted.

The finished Air Dam in place

Finishing touches included adding threaded rods to the leading edge of the splitter (for both strength and adjustability) and JB Welding nuts to the inside of the fenders so that The Air Dam could be removed without completely disassembling what was to come next…

Part 4 - The Grill

This was another project that I was dreading, primarily because I only had a very vague idea of how to do it.  I already had ABS that I had originally purchased for the Air Dam but decided not to use because the sheets were only 24” X 12” and ¼” thick.  Due to the size of the opening in the front of the car, I was going to have to use 3 sheets somehow fastened together.
Melissa had been eager to help with the car so she was tasked with fabricating a prototype out of cardboard.  She finished the job in record time and it was perfect.  Unfortunately I didn’t take any pictures of her pattern, but the pictures of The Grill that follow are exact duplicates of the pattern she created, so obviously, she nailed it.

The first steps went quickly; layout ABS pieces & tape them together.  Tape Melissa’s pattern to the plastic and trace an outline.  Use a straight edge to clean up lines and ensure that measurements are consistent between both sides.  Use a drill and step bit to cut radii into corners, use a jigsaw to make straight line cuts.
I knew that heating and bending plastic this thick was going to be a challenge, so the pieces that needed big adjustments were placed into the oven to heat soak.  Then we used a heat gun to soften the plastic where the bends needed to be. 

While I was cutting the plastic, Carl was cutting and painting expanded steel mesh that would fasten the three pieces together and provide the same sort of vents as the real M1.
Next came the actual assembly.  Drilling holes and popping rivets.

Assembling the driver’s side and center section (note the notch cut to clear the tow hook)

The finished Grill

The final part of assembly was figuring out how to mount the grill to the car.  This turned out to be pretty easy.  Fasteners at each end and three custom fabricated brackets in the middle were enough to robustly install the thing.

Part 5 - The Paint

As I had mentioned, the original plan was to paint the car in classic BMW M1 Procar (a mid-‘80s BMW M1 specific racing series) colors; tri-color stripes on a white field. 

Plan A (it looked so easy!)
Our plan had a lot going for it.  With the car already white, the paint job would be relatively easy and the car was going to be instantly recognizable to anybody that knew anything about BMW “Works” colors.  It was the “recognizable” factor that turned out to be a problem.  By this point in time we had been doing LeMons research for quite a while and one of the things that our research turned up was that the paint scheme we planned to do had been already been done.  Not just once, but quite a few times, including two cars at the same race with this paint scheme.  Our stunningly original and clever idea was a dud.  After a lot more surfing the intertubes and discarding a few other ideas for paint schemes, we decided to go with classic Marlboro livery which had been used by a couple different BMW M1s.  We didn’t want it to actually say “Marlboro” though (R.J. Reynolds wasn’t actually sponsoring us, why advertise for them?), so the search was on for a Marlboro parody.  We finally settled on Laramie (an actual cigarette brand that went out of business in the ‘50s).  Laramie is a brand of cigarettes satirized on The Simpsons.  Sure, the idea wasn’t particularly original (or our own), but we were beginning to feel a time crunch.

Plan B
Painting was relatively easy.  Find a few decent pictures of the real car.  Tape things off and apply paint with rollers and brushes.

The results are stunning and speak for themselves…





Part 19

First Start

On Saturday, we started the car for the first time.  It fired right up, surprisingly, and we ran it for about 7 minutes until the water temp started coming up.  Unfortunately, it appeared that we had an oil leak from somewhere in the motor.
So looks like we get to practice tearing the engine out of the car!  Turns out it doesn't take long, only about 30-45 minutes.



During disassembly of the engine, it was pretty obvious where the problem was:
And that's all it takes; one crushed o-ring...

Monday, February 13, 2012

Part 18

February Update

36 days and counting until our inaugural race at Sears Point, March 24-25. 

Crunch time.

Since the last update waaaay back in January, we've made a little more progress.  We had planned to try to start it this last weekend, but things didn't exactly work out that way.

Saturday
We put a few gallons of premixed fuel in the car so that we could fire up the fuel pump and check the system for leaks.  After figuring out our fancy fuel jugs (namely, not having fuel spitting back out of the fill neck all over the garage floor), we turned on the fuel pump.  Everything seemed good, until we noticed that the secondaries in the carb were literally filling with fuel.  That ain't normal.

I had to take a break to make a run to the airport to pick up the wife from a business trip to Canada, and when I got back, Van had stopped the flood of fuel into the carb, but the motor had quite a bit of fuel in it at that point.  Probably not a good idea to try to fire it up inside the garage...  We decided that we'd finish up some odds and ends that day, then roll the car into the driveway on Sunday and give her a whirl.

I began media-blasting the original engine components and made a sad discovery.  Although this engine was running when we bought it, it's wonder it wasn't dripping coolant like crazy.


There is a good material missing around the gasket channels, making it nearly impossible to get a good seal between the rotor houseings and the irons.  These things are scrap, unfortunately.  Guess we need to look for some replacements on Craigslist or the junk yard.

Sunday
This car was originally sold in California, and comes complete with all of the overkill emissions apparatus that was required on all cars in 1980.  That included all manner of sensors, solenoids, smog pump, vacuum valves, hoses, wires, and an emissions control unit.  I'm convinced that the sole purpose of the system was to sacrifice power to save the whales, or manatees, or whatever.  Brand new, this car was supposed to put out around 100 hp.  Over time, just due to the age of the internal components of the engine, carbon build-up, etc., this figure had to have diminished substantially.  Add to that the power-robbing benefit of the California smog system, and we were probably down to a peppy 65 horses.

In the course of tearing the car apart, we removed all of the emissions crap.  The only exception is the ECU, because I originally thought that it was required to trigger the igniter module to fire the leading and trailing spark plugs.  Turns out the ECU is not needed, and that's a relief (one less thing to break).

That left us with only the igniter module, the two igniters, and the distributor.  Seems simple, right?  After 5 hours of trial and error, I can tell you that it was not as simple as we thought.  Actually, we might have made it more difficult than it needed to be.

Sunday, we rolled the car out into the driveway.  I suggested that we pull a plug wire and check to make sure we're getting spark, before we actually turn on the fuel and try to start the motor, and that's where it all started.  We weren't getting any spark on the #1 leading plug.  We double-checked our set-up (we kind of had things mocked up to make sure it would run, then we'd finish the ignition install after) and found a wire from the distributor that needed to be connected to 12 volts.  After that was remedied, still no spark.  We then embarked on a 5-hour journey of mickey mouse jury-rigging, half-assed tests from the marginally useful Haynes manual, and trying every combination of wiring to try to get some fire to the plugs; all with no success.

We swapped out one of the igniters; no luck.  We removed the igniter box and pried the cover off to see what's inside this magic box.  We found the design of the thing to be kind of odd, and without a schematic of the circuits, we could only guess as to what it was doing.  Most of the components inside were pretty standard: resistors, diodes, transistors.  But there were two odd-looking components that neither of us had seen before, which Van appropriately dubbed Thing 1 and Thing 2.  They had some manufacturer's markings on them, but we were unable to find anything useful on the interwebz.  We knew the car ran when we bought it, and we hadn't done anything that could have reasonably resulted in damage.  We had to assume we just had it connected wrong.

We re-installed it in the car and tried again with the same results.  After another hour of standing around in the cold staring at it, trying different connections, discussing the possibility of modifying it to a direct fire system or performing the MSD6 mod, we decided to bag it for the day and spend some time researching the problem.

About a half hour later, I receive a text:

Van: I'm wondering if that connector with 2 leads that we jumpered to 12V was actually supposed to have voltage on it.
Me: Voltage out? Instead of in? Not sure which ones you mean.
Van: Or nothing at all.  I'm not sure what connector that is, but the ignitor already has 12V from the coil hot side.  I mean the connector that was also supposed to fire the trailing plugs.
Me: So the ones in the igniter test (GO & BR)?
Van: Yes, those ones.

I scurry off to the garage, simply remove the aligator clip from the ONE wire that we never thought to change during the 5 hours of trial and error, and gave it a try.  Two things became immediately apparent:
  1. If you're going to push the start button, you'd better make sure the car is not in gear (or at least that there's nothing of value in front of the car).
  2. We now have spark! 
Now, I take full responsibility for determining that, for some reason, that little black wire with the red stripe just had to be connected to 12V.  What's embarrassing is that I've been working on electronics in one form or another for over 15 years, and Van even longer.  We're both pretty good troubleshooters, but for some reason it never dawned on either of us to question the reason for having that wire connected.  Lesson re-learned.

Monday, we try again. Hopefully she rumbles to life.

Monday, January 16, 2012

Part 17

January Update...

I know it's been a while since the last post, so here's a general update on what's been going on.  I got the rear window cut and installed.  Turned out better than I thought it would...


Van's done a kick-ass job on fabricating the front air dam from ABS plastic.


I installed the brake cooling ducts (need to replace the zip ties with hose clamps, but they're basically complete).



Van added some steel mesh to protech the brake ducts and the radiators.


Van and Carl installed the padding on the roll cage and transmission tunnel.


 I found out the hard way that the oil pan has to be installed BEFORE the engine is installed in the car.  I ended up having to take a good portion of the steering rack apart to gain access to underside of the engine.  I installed studs so we don't have to use the original oil pan bolts.  This will make subsequent oil pan removals much easier. 

I also installed an oil pan baffle that Van fabricated.  The baffle is intended to keep the oil in the lower portion of the pan so that the oil pickup tube is submerged the majority of the time.  Without a baffle, during cornering the oil could slosh to one side away from the pickup tube, which can effect the efficiency of the oiling system.

I also found out the hard way that if the oil dip stick has to be removed to install the baffle, said baffle should probably have a hole in it for the dip stick to pass through.  Unfortunately, I didn't come to that realization until the baffle and pan had been installed.  So I got to crawl back under the car and take everything back off so Van could put another hole in the baffle.


Batter box and batter are installed.  We actually powered up the car and I was surprized to find that everything works!  I was sure that at least one thing would be wired incorrectly...


Van installed the brake proportioning valve and the master cylinder, fabricated all new brake lines, and bled everything out.  No leaks!  Things are going TOO smoothly...


I recieved the removable steering wheel hub on Friday.  I had to cut off the stock adapter from the back of the steering wheel, painted it, then drilled holes for the hub.  We decided to keep the OEM steering wheel because most aftermarket wheels quite a bit smaller.  Since the advent of power steering, there's much less effort involved in turning your car's wheels, even at a stop.  Our car does not have power steering; a larger wheel will give more leverage.

The hub has wiring and terminals for a horn, if you were to use it in a street car, but I'm going to use it for the push-to-talk switch for our radio.  That way, we'll be able to remove the wheel without having to worry about any wires.





We're getting close to actually starting the thing up!  We have to put some oil and premixed fuel in it, install the drive belt for the alternator and water pump, align the distributor and install the plug wires, then see what happens.  Once the car is running, I can install the ECU, finalize the interior electrical isntallation, get the switch panel installed, etc.

68 days to go...